Talk to Jeff

Neighborhood · live FMLS IDX

Casteel Homes for Sale in Bethlehem, GA

Homes for sale in the Casteel neighborhood of Bethlehem, Barrow County, from current FMLS IDX inventory. Live list-price medians, price per square foot, assigned schools and how Casteel compares with Bethlehem overall.

See newest homesFind an areaEstimate a payment

Casteel, Bethlehem, GA market at a glance

Median list price
$384,490
n=12
Median list price per SF
$170
n=12 · 2,223 SF typical
Median days listed
56
n=12
New in the last 30 days
2
1 in the last 7

Median list price is in line with Bethlehem, GA (102 homes, median $384,490).

FMLS IDXLive FMLS IDX data as of Oct 27, 2026, 8:09 AM ET. Figures are list prices from current FMLS IDX inventory (Active, Active Under Contract and Pending), not sales prices or appraisals. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Find an area

Schools and nearby neighborhoods

Schools as reported in Casteel listings, and the Bethlehem neighborhoods with the most homes for sale.

High school zones

As reported in each listing. Verify with the school district.

  1. Apalachee HighBarrow County12 homes · $384K

Middle schools

  1. Haymon-Morris MiddleBarrow County12 homes · $384K

Elementary schools

  1. Yargo ElementaryBarrow County11 homes · $384K

Other Bethlehem neighborhoods

  1. Apalachee HillsBethlehem7 homes · $376K
  2. Appaloosa ParkBethlehem6 homes · $415K
  3. River MeadowsBethlehem3 homes · $555K
  4. RivermillBethlehem3 homes · $327K
  5. WynterberryBethlehem3 homes · $445K
  6. Apalachee FallsBethlehem2 homes · $349K
  7. Arden MeadowsBethlehem2 homes · $355K
  8. Austin SpringsBethlehem2 homes · $549K
See all 22

Just listed

Newest homes for sale in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA

Sorted by listing date. Showing 1 to 12 of 12.

FMLS IDXLive FMLS IDX data as of Oct 27, 2026, 8:09 AM ET. Figures are list prices from current FMLS IDX inventory (Active, Active Under Contract and Pending), not sales prices or appraisals. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Payment estimate

Payment on a median-priced home in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA

Prefilled with the median list price of $384,490 and this week's average rate. Change anything to see your number.

Loan type
Estimated monthly payment

$2,935/mo

Principal and interest
$2,377
Property tax
$288
Home insurance
$125
Mortgage insurance
$144
Loan amount
$346,041
Cash down
$38,449

This is an estimate only. Not a lender, not a loan offer and not a rate quote. Rates: Freddie Mac PMMS weekly average for 2026-10-22: 30-yr 7.32%, 15-yr 6.68%. Tax uses about 0.9% of price per year; insurance assumes $1,500 a year. Conventional adds 0.5% a year mortgage insurance under 20% down; FHA uses 3.5% minimum down, a 1.75% upfront premium financed and 0.55% a year MIP; VA adds a 2.15% funding fee financed under 5% down and no monthly MI. Talk to a licensed lender for a real quote.

Inside the numbers

What is for sale in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA

Home types

  • Single-family homes12 100%median $384,490, $170/SF

Bedrooms

  • 1-2 bd0 0%
  • 3 bd1 8%
  • 4 bd7 58%
  • 5+ bd4 33%

List price

  • Under $300K0 0%
  • $300K to $500K12 100%
  • $500K to $750K0 0%
  • $750K to $1M0 0%
  • $1M and up0 0%

Status

  • Active8 67%
  • Active Under Contract0 0%
  • Pending4 33%

Ask Jeff

Questions about homes in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA?

Send a note with your price range, timing and must-haves. Jeff will reply by email.

From the live numbers

Casteel, Bethlehem, GA home market FAQ

How many homes are for sale in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA right now?

12 residential listings in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA are in current FMLS IDX inventory as of Oct 27, 2026, 8:09 AM ET: 8 Active, 0 Active Under Contract, 4 Pending. 2 were listed in the last 30 days.

What is the median list price for a home in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA?

The median list price is $384,490 across 12 priced listings. That is in line with the Bethlehem, GA median of $384,490. These are asking prices, not closed sales or appraisals.

What is the median list price per square foot in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA?

$170 per square foot (median of 12 listings with reported square footage), with a median home size of 2,223 square feet.

What kinds of homes are for sale in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA?

Single-family homes: 12 (100%), median $384,490.

How long have homes in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA been on the market?

The median listing has been on the market 56 days, measured from the listing contract date across 12 listings.

What is the estimated monthly payment on a median-priced home in Casteel, Bethlehem, GA?

About $2,935 per month at $384,490 with 10% down on a 30-year conventional loan at 7.32% (Freddie Mac PMMS), including estimated property tax (about 0.9% a year), $1,500 a year for insurance and mortgage insurance. Estimate only, not a lender. Use the calculator on this page to change the inputs.

Figures are list prices from current FMLS IDX inventory (Active, Active Under Contract and Pending), not sales prices or appraisals.

Beyond homes

Also exploring Georgia investment real estate?

Jeff Crowe is a local, full-service agent with CENTURY 21 The Avenues who also works with buyers and sellers of apartment buildings, churches, commercial property and land across Georgia. The pages below are other property types and investor research, separate from the homes listed on this page.

Other property types for sale

Investor research and tools

Thinking about a rental or a building instead? Send Jeff a message.

FMLS IDX Logo

Listings identified with the FMLS IDX logo come from FMLS and are held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website. The listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. If you believe any FMLS listing contains material that infringes your copyrighted work please click here to review our DMCA policy and learn how to submit a takedown request. ©2026 First Multiple Listing Service, Inc.