Active9 days listed

580 Highland Avenue NE

Atlanta, GA 30312 · Fulton County

  • 2units
  • 0.13ac lot
  • 1920built

MultifamilyDuplex

List price

$595,000

$297,500 per unit

Request underwriting

Location

580 Highland Avenue NE, Atlanta GA 30312

Interactive map

Loads on click

List Price$595,000
2 Units$297,500 per unit
Estimated Year 1 Cash Flow$-16,278Rent upside or negotiations may be available
3.3%Est. Cap Rate
-10.9%Est. CoC
0.54xEst. DSCR
Below 1.0x DSCRListing evidence · class A
Rents2 / 2 units
Who paysWater tenant · Elec tenant · Gas tenant · Trash owner
OccupancyNot in remarks
FinancialsMLS GI/NOI empty · Tax $10,666 (2026)
Description

Property Description

Location, character, and proven rental history come together at this classic Old Fourth Ward duplex, offering an exceptional opportunity for investors and owner-occupants alike. Each one-bedroom, one-bath residence blends historic bungalow charm with everyday functionality, featuring a mix of hardwood floors, high ceilings, decorative fireplaces, clawfoot tubs, generous closets, pantries, and dedicated laundry. A welcoming front porch, shared rear deck, fenced backyard, and off-street parking accessed from the rear alley add to the appeal. Ideally positioned at the intersection of Old Fourth Ward and Inman Park, 580 Highland puts some of Atlanta’s best dining, shopping, neighborhood destinations, and the BeltLine within easy reach. With an established rental history and flexible possibilities, this property offers multiple paths forward: maintain it as an income-producing duplex, live in one unit while renting the other, or reimagine it as a single-family Craftsman bungalow. Historic character, an unbeatable intown location, and versatility make 580 Highland a compelling opportunity.
Listing facts

From this record

  • In-place DSCR 0.54x below 1.0 on default debt
  • Owner-paid: trash, maint

2 doors on the listing. Generic market notes are below the fold.

FMLS IDXFMLS #7867898 · Listing Provided By Dossier · 404-465-4333

Unit Mix & Available Rent Roll

Breakdown based on data provided in the listing· HUD Small Area FMR (ZIP 30312, FY2027)shown for comparison

UnitBedsBathsMonthly RentHUD SAFMRElecGasWaterGarbMaint
Unit 111$1,795$1,990+$195NNNYY
Unit 211$1,495$1,990+$495NNNYY
Total2 units$3,290Y = owner-paid ·, = unknown

* Rent roll information is taken from the available listing data. Many multifamily listings do not include complete or verified tenant financials. Always verify actual rents, leases, and operating expenses during due diligence. HUD Small Area Fair Market Rents (ZIP-level payment standards) are published by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and are shown for comparison only.

Calculator

Investment Calculator

Starts from list price and unit count. Pre-filled from From Rent Roll.. Override any value.

$
$
$
%
$
$
%
$
$
$
$

Repairs, pest, landscaping, cleaning, admin. Water and trash are separate lines. Electric/gas off when tenant-paid.

Conventional = fully amortizing. Commercial = shorter call + balloon. Seller finance = below-market note. Cash = no loan.

%
%
yrs
Income
Gross Potential Income–
Effective Gross Income–
Expenses
Taxes–
Insurance–
Management–
Water–
Trash–
Electric–
R&M–
Total Operating Expenses–
Expense Ratio–
Returns
Net Operating Income–
Cap Rate–
Price / Unit–
Financing & Cash Flow
Annual Debt Service–
Year 1 Cash Flow–
Cash-on-Cash–
DSCR–

Published from unit rents. Calculator defaults match the hero stack.

Coverage rules
  • GPI pre-fills only from MLS GI, a building-total UnitTypes row, or a rent roll covering ≥ 80% of doors.
  • A single sample rent is not averaged across the building.
  • Vacancy floor is max(5%, 100 − present occupancy in remarks).
  • Mgmt 8% at 8+ units, else 10%. Insurance $800/door. R&M $800/door.
  • Utility allowances turn on only when the who-pays grid or remarks say owner-paid.
  • SAFMR push is mix-weighted and hidden when the sample is extrapolated from thin coverage.
  • Commercial = 30% / 7.75% / 25-yr amort. Conventional = 25% / 7.75% / 30-yr. Cash = 100% equity, no debt service. CoC = NOI ÷ price.
Screenable · failed ask · sub-1.0x

Jeff’s Investment Take

Market data · November 2026

Working thesis

In-place DSCR 0.54x does not cover default debt, the listing only screens if the price or the rent moves.

The ask is on the Fulton County failure path, priced with inventory that expired instead of clearing. +21.0% Voucher Spread™ is the listed path to thicken NOI, only if those rents are collectible on this building.

  • Modeled debt service exceeds NOI at 0.54x. That is the binding constraint, not the badge.
  • In-place rents sit under ZIP SAFMR. Closing that gap (~$8,280/yr GPI) is what would change the DSCR and the gross.
  • Published cap 3.3% sits at or under county sold NOI cap 6.6%.
  • In-place DSCR 0.54x below 1.0 on default debt
  • Owner-paid: trash, maint
Est. Cap Rate3.3%
Est. Cash-on-Cash-10.9%
Est. DSCR0.54xconventional
Price / Unit$297,500
vs Local Close $/Door68% above recent close $/door
Same thesis · failure-zone checkFulton County expired tape

This ask sits with inventory that expired here without re-listing. List $297,500/door vs expired median $212,500 and closed $176,583. Published NOI cap 3.3% is at or below the expired median 6.3%. Failures in this county sat 94 days. 44 expired buildings in sample. Not a do-not-buy, it is the price path that failed to clear.

Open the Failures tab →
Same thesis · Voucher Spread™vs HUD Small Area FMR · ZIP 30312 (FY2027)
Voucher Spread™+21.0%vs SAFMR
Monthly rent gap+$690
Annual GPI upside+$8,280

Strong Voucher Spread™ of +21.0% , in-place rents sit below the HUD Small Area FMR benchmark for this ZIP. If every unit reached current HUD Small Area FMR, modeled gross income rises by roughly $8,280 per year. This is a listing-level signal, not a metro average. Confirm with comps and the actual rent roll.

Local market contextFulton County
Med. close $/door$176,583116 closed · 12 mo
Med. asking rent$1,450
Months of supply11.1Active ÷ (12-mo closed ÷ 12)
County sold gross9.7%Rent ÷ close · T12 sold tape
County asking gross8.9%Rent ÷ list · live asks
County sold NOI cap6.6%Calculator stack on closes

Modeled from available FMLS data, unit mix, and operating assumptions and Fulton County benchmarks, and HUD Small Area FMR (ZIP-level) for Voucher Spread™ rent-gap context. DSCR and cash-on-cash use conventional terms (25% down / 7% / 30-yr) for ≤4 units. Always verify with current rent roll and expenses.

Estimated offer

Price that clears 1.25× DSCR

Modeled basis so in-place NOI covers debt at 1.25× on default conventional terms. Not a bid. If you want to offer, including below this number or below list, start here. Jeff will request the rent roll and T-12 before anyone writes a number.

Estimated offer$258,521$129,261 / door · 57% below list $595,000
  • Solve: max purchase price where modeled NOI ÷ annual debt service = 1.25×.
  • Debt assumed at 25% down / 7% / 30-yr · conventional. Vacancy 5.0%, management 10% of EGI, modeled opex (tax record + insurance / R&M allowances + trash).
  • List is $595,000. The 1.25× basis sits below ask, so financing at list is tight unless rents or expenses move.

Change GPI, expenses, or terms in the Investment Calculator to re-solve. Always confirm with the rent roll and T-12 before writing an offer.

Property Financials

Request the rent roll and full expenses on this property

Get the current rent roll, T-12, and full operating expense details for this property.

No obligation. Just the property financials.

Inquire

Request underwriting materials

Request the rent roll, expense detail, and a walkthrough of the modeled numbers for 580 Highland Avenue NE. Replies typically go out the same business day.

Investor list

New multifamily listings by email

New Atlanta Metro listings matched to your criteria, with modeled cash flow for screening. Georgia market notes included. Approval usually within 24–48 hours.

Request access

Licensed Georgia real estate agent.

Similar duplexes listings near Atlanta, GA

Active FMLS duplexes listings matched to this one on unit count and price, nearest to Atlanta, GA first.

Multifamily for sale: 627 Delmar Avenue SE, Atlanta
Active2 units

$599,000

2 units$299,500/unit

627 Delmar Avenue SE

Atlanta, GA · 98 days listed

FMLS IDXFMLS #7821211 · Listing Provided By Vision Residential Realty · 770-740-4766

Why it matchesSame city · 2 units · Similar price

Why it matchesSame city · 2 units · Similar price

Why it matchesSame city · 2 units · 7% above this price

Why it matchesSame city · 2 units · 13% above this price

Questions about this property

How do I schedule a showing or ask a question about this property?

Use the inquiry form on this page and include what you want to know and the days and times that work for you. Jeff Crowe will follow up.

Where does the listing information come from?

Listing details come from the MLS and are provided by Dossier. Confirm them before making an offer.

Is this property still available?

This page shows the status reported in the MLS (Active) as of the last sync. Status can change quickly, so ask through the form to confirm before you tour.

Are the cap rate and cash-on-cash figures on this page verified?

No. Modeled figures are an independent estimate for screening only. Confirm them with the seller rent roll, T-12 and your lender terms before relying on them.

FMLS IDXListing data last updated from FMLS . Listing details are provided by the listing brokerage through the MLS. Verify before relying on them. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Disclaimer

Important Investment Information

Median estimated cap, cash-on-cash, and DSCR require MLS gross income or NOI, a dated broker package, a listing building total, or a unit rent roll covering at least 80% of doors. Thin records stay Incomplete, those yields are not printed in the hero or on cards. The calculator is a labeled scenario, not in-place income.

When a line is missing we use disclosed defaults only inside the calculator: vacancy floor of max(5%, 100 − present occupancy in remarks); management 8% of EGI at 8+ units otherwise 10%; insurance $800 per door; R&M $800 per door. Utility allowances turn on only if the who-pays grid or remarks say owner-paid (water $900–1,800 per door until a T-12). A single who-pays row does not set the building. We do not use an all-in “other” of $1,100 per door, and we do not average one sample rent across the building.

Rent coverage 100%, yields published from unit rents

Some figures shown on this page are estimated because complete data was not provided in the listing. Estimated values are clearly marked.

Any estimated or modeled figures represent the independent analysis of Jeff Crowe / Century 21 The Avenues and are not supplied by FMLS or the listing broker.

This website and its content are for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, tax, or real estate advice. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. You should always conduct your own thorough due diligence, verify all data independently, review the physical condition of the property, and consult with your own qualified attorney, accountant, and investment advisor before making any purchase decision.

FMLS · Updated Daily
FMLS IDX Logo

Listings identified with the FMLS IDX logo come from FMLS and are held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website. The listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. If you believe any FMLS listing contains material that infringes your copyrighted work please click here to review our DMCA policy and learn how to submit a takedown request. ©2026 First Multiple Listing Service, Inc.