
$2,100,000
5 bd6 ba6,113 SFSingle-family home
5186 Howard Road
Cumming, GA 30040 · 69 days listed
FMLS #7832996 · Listing Provided By Georgia Homes and Land, Inc. · 770-561-5483
Active9 days listedListed

Location
2250 Old Alpharetta Road, Cumming GA 30041
A truly rare opportunity to own TWO beautifully designed homes situated on a combined **4.4 acres** in highly sought-after Forsyth County, just minutes from GA 400, Halcyon, shopping, dining, and entertainment! This one-of-a-kind property blends historic farmhouse charm with modern luxury, exceptional craftsmanship, and endless possibilities for multigenerational living. Originally built in 1917, the historic farmhouse is filled with character, history, and timeless details that simply cannot be replicated. Reportedly the first home in Forsyth County to have electric lighting, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence has been thoughtfully updated while preserving its original charm. Soaring ceilings, original wood ceilings in the kitchen and dining room, antique French doors with glass knobs, and a beautiful vaulted living room with a gas fireplace create a warm and inviting atmosphere. Every detail has been carefully considered, from the antique English kitchen island dating to approximately 1870 to the hand-selected European lighting. A spacious covered front porch, enclosed sunroom, and fenced backyard complete the farmhouse setting. Adding incredible flexibility is the detached garage with a private upstairs apartment featuring a full kitchen, bedroom, full bathroom, and living area, ideal for extended family or guests. An additional spacious finished room on the back of the garage, complete with a half bath and HVAC, offers the perfect opportunity for a home office, creative studio, or private workspace. Built in 2021, the second residence offers 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms with beautiful high-end finishes and carefully curated selections throughout. Architectural wood beams, a stunning limestone fireplace, a kitchen with an antique wood-topped island, natural gas cooktop, double ovens, and warming drawer create an elegant yet comfortable living environment. Outside, enjoy your own private retreat with a heated spa, swimming pool, artificial turf, beautiful stonework, mature landscaping, and fenced pool area. A picturesque pond situated between the two residences enhances the peaceful, estate-like setting, creating a beautiful separation between the homes. The grounds feature mature trees, thoughtfully designed landscaping, and a sense of privacy that is increasingly difficult to find this close to everything. Properties offering TWO full-size homes, additional guest accommodations, 4.4 acres, and this level of craftsmanship are exceptionally rare in this desirable location. Whether you're looking for multigenerational living, a private family compound, or simply the luxury of space without sacrificing location, this extraordinary property offers an opportunity unlike anything else on the market. Both homes are being sold together as one exceptional estate.
Figures are list prices from current inventory (Active, Active Under Contract and Pending), not sales prices or appraisals.
As reported in the listing. Verify with the school district.
FMLS #7865978 · Listing Provided By The Connection Real Estate · 678-467-2489
Payment estimate
Prefilled with the list price of $2,100,000 and this week's average rate. Change anything to see your number.
$14,720/mo
This is an estimate only. Not a lender, not a loan offer and not a rate quote. Rates: Freddie Mac PMMS weekly average for 2026-11-12: 30-yr 7.11%, 15-yr 6.45%. Tax uses the annual tax amount in the listing; insurance assumes $1,500 a year. Conventional adds 0.5% a year mortgage insurance under 20% down; FHA uses 3.5% minimum down, a 1.75% upfront premium financed and 0.55% a year MIP; VA adds a 2.15% funding fee financed under 5% down and no monthly MI. Talk to a licensed lender for a real quote.
2250 Old Alpharetta Road, Cumming, GA 30041

$2,100,000
5 bd6 ba6,113 SFSingle-family home
Cumming, GA 30040 · 69 days listed
FMLS #7832996 · Listing Provided By Georgia Homes and Land, Inc. · 770-561-5483

$2,100,000
5 bd7 ba5,800 SFSingle-family home
Cumming, GA 30040 · 12 days listed
FMLS #7864038 · Listing Provided By Mark Spain Real Estate · 770-886-9000

$2,149,000
5 bd7 ba4,741 SFSingle-family home
Cumming, GA 30028 · 123 days listed
FMLS #7806392 · Listing Provided By Ansley Real Estate · 770-862-4408

$2,025,000
4 bd5 ba5,356 SFSingle-family home
Cumming, GA 30028 · 59 days listed
FMLS #7838333 · Listing Provided By Keller Williams Realty Atlanta Partners · 678-468-4500

$1,999,999
6 bd5 ba6,083 SFSingle-family home
Cumming, GA 30028 · 215 days listed
FMLS #7760398 · Listing Provided By Virtual Properties Realty.Net, LLC. · 770-653-3493

$1,999,000
6 bd9 ba9,259 SFSingle-family home
Cumming, GA 30041 · Creekstone Estates · 42 days listed
FMLS #7849116 · Listing Provided By Century 21 Lindsey and Pauley · 706-692-3533
Use the "Inquire about this listing" form on this page and include the days and times that work for you. A licensed agent will follow up to set up a showing.
Send your question through the form on this page. Listing details come from the MLS and are provided by the listing brokerage, so confirm them before making an offer.
This page shows the status reported in the MLS (Active) as of the last update. Status can change quickly, so ask through the form to confirm before you tour.
It uses the list price, an average mortgage rate, the tax amount in the listing (or an estimated tax rate when none is given), estimated insurance and any HOA dues in the listing. It is an estimate only, not a loan offer. Talk to a licensed lender for a real quote.
See the similar homes section on this page, or browse homes for sale in Cumming, GA.
Thinking about selling?
The Cumming home market report shows recent closings, median sale price, sale-to-list ratio and days on market from FMLS. A local agent will walk through the sales that match your home and build a pricing and listing plan with you.
Closed sales research
Monthly closed-sales reports from FMLS for the area around this home: median sale price, $/SF, days on market and sale-to-list ratio. These are market-wide numbers, separate from this home listing.
Listing data last updated from FMLS . Figures are list prices from current inventory (Active, Active Under Contract and Pending), not sales prices or appraisals. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Listings identified with the FMLS IDX logo come from FMLS and are held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website. The listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. If you believe any FMLS listing contains material that infringes your copyrighted work please click here to review our DMCA policy and learn how to submit a takedown request. ©2026 First Multiple Listing Service, Inc.