Live listings

Homes for Sale in Bethlehem, GA

Bethlehem is an incorporated town in Barrow County on Georgia Highway 11, four miles south of Winder, nine miles north of Monroe and about 18 miles from Athens off Highway 316.

Just listed

Newest homes for sale in Bethlehem, GA

Sorted by newest listed. Showing 1 to 24 of 102.

Sort and filter

FMLS IDXListing data last updated from FMLS . Figures are list prices from current inventory (Active, Active Under Contract and Pending), not sales prices or appraisals. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Bethlehem, GA market at a glance

Median list price
$385,000
n=102
Median list price per SF
$180
n=101 · 2,325 SF typical
Median days listed
72
n=102
New in the last 30 days
22
5 in the last 7

Median list price is in line with Barrow County (592 homes, median $385,000).

FMLS IDXListing data last updated from FMLS . Figures are list prices from current inventory (Active, Active Under Contract and Pending), not sales prices or appraisals. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Closed sales, not list prices

What homes in Bethlehem, GA sold for in the last 12 months

Homes sold
202
Nov 2025 to Oct 2026
Typical sale price
$383,500
Median of all closings
Sold price per SF
$169
Median of all closings
Days on market
27
Median of all closings
Sale to list price
100.0%
Median ratio
Median price change
+0.9%
vs. Nov 2024 to Oct 2025

Today's median list price of $385,000 is in line with the typical sale price of $383,500 over the last 12 months.

Months of supply in Bethlehem, GA

Months of supply gauge: 6.4 months, Buyer's market. Scale 0 to 12 months: under 4 seller's market, 4 to 6 balanced, over 6 buyer's market.46012+ mo.BalancedSeller'sBuyer's
Buyer's market
6.4 months of supply

77 active ÷ 12 closings in October 2026. Trailing-12 pace: 4.6 months (average 17 closings a month).

Active listings only (not pending or under contract) divided by FMLS closed sales. Under 4 months leans to sellers, 4 to 6 is balanced, above 6 leans to buyers.

FMLS closed residential sales, Nov 2025 to Oct 2026, data as of Nov 14, 2026. Sale price, $/SF and days on market are medians of every closing in the window (pooled, not a blend of monthly medians). Read the full sales report.

Find an area

Find homes in Bethlehem

The areas with the most homes for sale right now, by current listing count. Search to jump to any other.

Top neighborhoods

  1. CasteelBethlehem12 homes · $381K
  2. Apalachee HillsBethlehem8 homes · $388K
  3. Appaloosa ParkBethlehem6 homes · $415K
  4. Mallard CreekBethlehem3 homes · $490K
  5. River MeadowsBethlehem3 homes · $555K
  6. RivermillBethlehem3 homes · $310K
  7. Apalachee FallsBethlehem2 homes · $349K
  8. Arden MeadowsBethlehem2 homes · $350K
See all 20

Top high school districts

As reported in each listing. Verify with the school district.

  1. Apalachee HighBarrow County67 homes · $375K
  2. Archer HighGwinnett County30 homes · $426K
  3. Monroe Area HighWalton County4 homes · $415K

ZIP codes

  1. ZIP 30620101 homes · $385K

Counties

  1. Barrow County68 homes · $372K
  2. Gwinnett County30 homes · $426K
  3. Walton County4 homes · $415K

Other Barrow County cities

  1. Homes for sale in Winder, GA273 homes · $374K
  2. Homes for sale in Auburn, GA119 homes · $360K
  3. Homes for sale in Statham, GA82 homes · $399K
  4. Homes for sale in Hoschton, GA28 homes · $853K
  5. Homes for sale in Braselton, GA20 homes · $439K
  6. Homes for sale in Monroe, GA2 homes · $344K

About the area

Living in Bethlehem, GA

Bethlehem is an incorporated town in Barrow County on Georgia Highway 11, four miles south of Winder, nine miles north of Monroe and about 18 miles from Athens off Highway 316.

The town takes its name from Bethlehem Methodist Church, established in 1796. The name was suggested by Judson L. Moore, a gospel songwriter and publisher who lived here, and the street names all come from the story of the birth of Christ. Each Christmas a live nativity is held on the town square, and hundreds of people bring their cards to the Bethlehem Post Office for its holiday postmark.

Barrow County Schools serves Bethlehem. Check with the district for the exact address.

Looking for new construction? Use the new construction link on this page. It shows only the homes listed as new construction.

In our official November 14, 2026 run, Bethlehem had 202 closings in the last 12 months, with a 12-month median sale price of $383,495. The Bethlehem market report has the full breakdown and updates on the 14th of each month.

The homes on this page are current listings, and each one shows its listing brokerage. If you have questions about a home here, or about selling in Bethlehem, send me a note with the form below.

Sources

Thinking about selling?

Selling a home in Bethlehem, GA? Start with what sold nearby

The Bethlehem, GA home sales report shows recent closings, median sale price, sale-to-list ratio and days on market from FMLS. Jeff Crowe will walk through the sales that match your home and build a pricing and listing plan with you.

Talk to Jeff about selling your home

Payment estimate

Payment on a median-priced home in Bethlehem, GA

Prefilled with the median list price of $385,000 and this week's average rate. Change anything to see your number.

Loan type
Estimated monthly payment

$2,889/mo

Principal and interest
$2,331
Property tax
$289
Home insurance
$125
Mortgage insurance
$144
Loan amount
$346,500
Cash down
$38,500

This is an estimate only. Not a lender, not a loan offer and not a rate quote. Rates: Freddie Mac PMMS weekly average for 2026-11-12: 30-yr 7.11%, 15-yr 6.45%. Tax uses about 0.9% of price per year; insurance assumes $1,500 a year. Conventional adds 0.5% a year mortgage insurance under 20% down; FHA uses 3.5% minimum down, a 1.75% upfront premium financed and 0.55% a year MIP; VA adds a 2.15% funding fee financed under 5% down and no monthly MI. Talk to a licensed lender for a real quote.

Inside the numbers

What is for sale in Bethlehem, GA

Home types

  • Single-family homes102 100%median $385,000, $180/SF

Bedrooms

  • 1-2 bd0 0%
  • 3 bd26 25%
  • 4 bd50 49%
  • 5+ bd26 25%

List price

  • Under $300K5 5%
  • $300K to $500K81 79%
  • $500K to $750K7 7%
  • $750K to $1M4 4%
  • $1M and up5 5%

Status

  • Active77 75%
  • Active Under Contract5 5%
  • Pending20 20%

Home listing alerts

Get email alerts for homes in Bethlehem

Set your price range, bedrooms and acreage. When a matching home is listed on FMLS, you get an email with the details. Change or stop alerts any time from the link in every email.

AreaBethlehem, GA

Ask Jeff

Questions about homes in Bethlehem, GA?

Send a note with your price range, timing and must-haves. Jeff will reply by email.

From the live numbers

Bethlehem, GA FAQ

How many homes are for sale in Bethlehem, GA right now?

102 residential listings in Bethlehem, GA are in current inventory as of Nov 15, 2026, 8:39 PM ET: 77 Active, 5 Active Under Contract, 20 Pending. 22 were listed in the last 30 days.

What is the median list price for a home in Bethlehem, GA?

The median list price is $385,000 across 102 priced listings. That is in line with the Barrow County median of $385,000. These are asking prices, not closed sales or appraisals.

What is the median list price per square foot in Bethlehem, GA?

$180 per square foot (median of 101 listings with reported square footage), with a median home size of 2,325 square feet.

What kinds of homes are for sale in Bethlehem, GA?

Single-family homes: 102 (100%), median $385,000.

How long have homes in Bethlehem, GA been on the market?

The median listing has been on the market 72 days, measured from the listing contract date across 102 listings.

Which neighborhoods in Bethlehem, GA have the most homes for sale?

Casteel (12, median $381,495), Apalachee Hills (8, median $387,750), Appaloosa Park (6, median $415,150), Mallard Creek (3, median $489,999), River Meadows (3, median $554,900).

What is the estimated monthly payment on a median-priced home in Bethlehem, GA?

About $2,889 per month at $385,000 with 10% down on a 30-year conventional loan at 7.11% (Freddie Mac PMMS), including estimated property tax (about 0.9% a year), $1,500 a year for insurance and mortgage insurance. Estimate only, not a lender. Use the calculator on this page to change the inputs.

Figures are list prices from current inventory (Active, Active Under Contract and Pending), not sales prices or appraisals.

FMLS IDX Logo

Listings identified with the FMLS IDX logo come from FMLS and are held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website. The listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. If you believe any FMLS listing contains material that infringes your copyrighted work please click here to review our DMCA policy and learn how to submit a takedown request. ©2026 First Multiple Listing Service, Inc.